The poem, Lady of Shallot, was made into a painting by Waterhouse. The painting in my opinion doesn't give a good interpretation of the poem. The painting itself just depicts this woman getting up from her chair and looking at the viewer as you see here. The story is about a woman who wants to escape the small island Shallot to see her true love Lancelot in Camelot. The woman looks mainly like she's trying to escape prison. In a way it has to do with the poem because she has heard rumors that if she stays in Shallot weaving then she would die. What I would do to change the painting is have her look out the window and out into the distant land of Camelot. There in the distance would be the knight Lancelot who she is looking to with starstruck eyes. Her weaving basket would be beside her and you would see the whole Camelot seen through the mirror that it talks about in the poem.
The next poem, the Fall of Icarus, was made into a painting by Bruegal. This painting was okay if you look at it closely. At first it looks like a normal scene in the Greek island, Crete. Only if you spend some time looking at it, like I did, do you actually notice Icarus drowning in a small corner. The painting itself is beautiful but in my opinion it should have more of a focus on Icarus. If I could actually paint something else besides stick people, Icarus would be a major focus, since the painting is about him. I would put him falling into the water with his wings wax wrapped all around him, pulling him down towards the dark ocean. Or I would also paint him flying up to the sky really close to the sun, with his wings slowly melting. The ocean would be below him and he would be looking down to what would seem his obvious death.
5 comments:
I agree with you that the Lady of Shallot painting doesn't give a good interpretation on the poem.
I mostly agree with your interpretation oon the Fall of Icarus but I think that they shouldn't focus on Icarus because nobody had noticed him drowning and I think that's what the painter wanted you to think.
(:
the lady of shallot doesn't gvie a good interpertation of the poem. it reminds me of a women who is running for her life.
i also agree with the fall of icarus should be focused on icarus instead of the island.
Great response! I totally agree with you on the fact that the lady of shallot painting just depic the poem. I love how detailed you were when describing both paintings! I love your bolg!!!!!!!!!!! lol
I like the way your paintings would be. It gives a really good interpretation of the actual story or poem itself.
The Lady of Shallot should have shown more emphasis on the mirror since that was the thing she did all day.
In the Fall of Icarus, it should have more on Icarus.
I agree with you about "The Lady of Shallot" painting. It didn't really give a good explaination or idea of the poem and the story behind it.
In "The Fall of Icarus" I also think they didn't focus on him. I think though that the painter didn't want anyone to notice him so that you can see a lesson well learned. =)
Post a Comment